Eli > Peyton ?

[FlyFreeCt]

I still see some Eli doubt in this bitch smh....O well, he's gonna get at least one more which should silence the rest of the haters...But as I said before, Eli is not a better QB than Peyton and Eli is my favorite QB in league history....He ain't Peyton, but would I trade him for Peyton?? Hell no!

 

[Bully_Pulpit]

Hes definately more durable plus hes entering his prime, we getting another ring

 

[BlackxChild]

It's not hate its facts he's not as clutch as you think and I put my money on the giants in both superbowls and Eli threw those games away and I'm calling it like I see it. You guys are denying the mistakes he DID make.

 

[FlyFreeCt]

It's not hate its facts he's not as clutch as you think and I put my money on the giants in both superbowls and Eli threw those games away and I'm calling it like I see it. You guys are denying the mistakes he DID make.

You nitpickin like hell...All QB's make mistakes, but if the defense doesn't make'em pay then there's nothing to go off of...You can't use shoulda/coulda/wouldas or "ifs"...Football is all about capitalizing off mistakes and making the most plays throughout the game, the team that does WINS, simple as that....The bottom line is that Eli steps up in the biggest moments and he has 2 rings to show for it...and he's outplayed one of the best QB's in the history of the league in both games...Bradt made crucial mistakes in that game and i still don't hear people discredting him..AND HE LOST...But having said that it doesn't make him any less of a QB, shit happens and ain't no player perfect...That pass to Deion Branch was AWFUL and could've potentially put them in position to win the game..see the word "Could've"...he didn't make the play...and the throw to Welker was a bad one even though he could've caught it....Eli on the other hand made perfect throws all 4th quarter and that can't be disputed...

 

[R.D.]

Is Eli Manning one of the greatest QB's of all time ? If your answer is No, then its not even discussion worthy

 

[Mrslim1]

Peyton lost for having MVP awards. What a loser.

2 Superbowl Rings > Than any regular season stat . U play to win championships not awards .

 

[BitchIWillSlapU]

Eli is a little retarded, but he is a BEAST

naw seriously though, as a LONG TIME Giants fans, I have my doubts about Eli up until this season to really be honest, but it is something about Eli on the road and late in the season and especially in the Playoffs, he seems have that extra Gear

I know one thing, Eli would not have thrown that INT on that Final Drive in the Super Bowl against the Saints like Big Brother did

only Joe Montana is better at the 2 Minute Drill then Eli IMO!

 

[Cutler 26 INT's LOL!]

Eli was puttin in work in the post-season this year but as far as pure skill and all that...I'm taking Peyton.

 

[Mrslim1]

Peyton lost for having MVP awards. What a loser.

2 Superbowl Rings > Than any regular season stat . U play to win championships not awards .

You are talking about 2 individuals and comparing them individually if I'm not mistaken. Super Bowl takes a team.

A QB with 1 Superbowl ring and 4 MVP Trophies >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> A QB with 2 Superbowl rings

With your logic Roger Staubach, Bob Griese, Ben Roethlisberger, Bart Starr and Jim Plunkett >>>>>>> Peyton Manning.

I think Peyton skill wise is better most of the QB's that have ever played this games . However the things you cant necessarily measure is what takes players over the top and that why I believe Eli is better than Peyton . Peyton is a all time great QB when it comes to stats , technique , running an offense etc . But there are many QB's I would take over Peyton in a big game . Because I know Peyton has a tendency to freeze in big moments . When it comes down to it , its all about who can win me the ring and at this point Eli is more reliable .

 

[R.D.]

If you think Eli is a better QB than Peyton, your football IQ comes into question and that freeze in big moments comment is bullshit

I remember Belechik not wanting to give Peyton the ball with like 2 minutes and going for it on 4th down cause he knew what would happen

 

[PanchoYoSancho]

Just further proof how ridiculous the championship argument has become.