Eli > Peyton ?

[woah316]

too be fair to Eli, now they win because of him, not in spite of him

To be fair to Peyton, The Giants D health the best offense in NFL history to 14 points, and 1 of the best years a QB has ever had to 20 points (shoulda been 6).

 

[Mrslim1]

.................

ESPN really gonna swagger jack me ?

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

too be fair to Eli, now they win because of him, not in spite of him

An they won because of him The entire 2008 playoffs including SB 42,where he had 2 TD's in the 4th quarter with one of the greatest drives in History when the D gave up a lead with 2 mins left.

Eli is the most disrespected SB MVP ever

 

[blackrain]

Eli has never played on a team as good as the 2003-2007 colts teams. They were loaded especially on offense

Plus the colts had fallen off, they were gonna be average THIS year with Peyton.

Take Eli off THIS giants team and they're 2 maybe 3 win squad

Now go look at the Colts defensive numbers those same years...the Colts have always had a terrible defense...outside of their 2 pash rushers, their most notable defensive player was Bob Sanders and he was injured more than he played...the Giants have consistently had a very strong defense...outside of this year, they've been a feared defensive team...hell last year they injured how many qb's?

 

[FlyFreeCt]

An they won because of him In SB, where he had 2 TD's in the 4th quarter with one of the greatest drives in History when the D gave up a lead with 2 mins left.

Eli is the most disrespected SB MVP ever

True shit 9/14 152yds and 2 td's in the 4th quarter (both trailing)...has to be one of the best 4th quarter statlines in super bowl history..

 

[Niggersauce]

No disrespect but after the 9ers get in that ass this week no one will be talking about Eli.

People just hype because the giants beat a seemingly unstoppable packers team. Eli is a SLEPT ON top 5 qb, but come on

 

[blackrain]

I will say this though, all of my best friends are Giants fans, and their biggest complaint about Eli is his tendency to just throw the ball into the air at times and get bailed out by his receivers...

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

True shit 9/14 152yds and 2 td's in the 4th quarter (both trailing)...has to be one of the best 4th quarter statlines in super bowl history..

That's what its all about, performing when the lights shine the brightest.

Probably my favorite 4th quarter of all time, in any sport.(given what was on the line)

 

[eyes low]

eli is about to carve up the 9ers d to show up drew bress then is gonna go either snatch ray lewis soul or tom bradys again

 

[R.D.]

this nigga brodie just jump at any chance to disrespect the GOAT Peyton.

Texans fan ?

son, let it go

 

[ClemsonKUjayhawks215]

So again all the people who say peyton doesnt have a defense what about in college when he was at Tennessee and went 0-4 ( in tennessee's biggest game every year) against Florida???????

 

[its....JOHN B]

So again all the people who say peyton doesnt have a defense what about in college when he was at Tennessee and went 0-4 ( in tennessee's biggest game every year) against Florida???????

its funny because if it wasnt for defense he would of never got that first ring, the way he played throughout the playoffs and in the superbowl it was like he was trying to lose, but his defense bailed him out, ill give him credit against the pats in the 2nd half of that game but if reche caldwell could of caught one of the two wide opens passes he would still be ringless

 

[Shane5140]

Eli has without a doubt has shown growth as a QB ever since 2008, but he is not greater than his brother. If Eli missed an entire season the Giants would win more than 2 games unlike the Colts.

 

[gman82]

Really? Smh. These threads

 

[A$AP_A$TON]

Nope........

 

[Fly society513]

Eli will always get disrespected and I'm ok with that, if he gets us another Super Bowl everyone's opinion doesn't really matter, he comes to play and dude never folds under pressure, there's no qb I rather have under center than Eli

I've always felt this way. Like i tell people he's our QB.

BTW as much as i like eli, he's not better than big bro. Ill give em being more clutch

[video=youtube;SVD0l3IS21g]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVD0l3IS21g&feature=related[/video]

 

[its....JOHN B]

some of yall are going overboard

 

[nujerz84]

I've always felt this way. Like i tell people he's our QB.

BTW as much as i like eli, he's not better than big bro. Ill give em being more clutch

[video=youtube;SVD0l3IS21g]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVD0l3IS21g&feature=related[/video]

LOL....Cooper blacksheep of the family... sucks dude was a top WR in the Country in HS... but a spine condition at Ole Miss ended his career.

 

[ClemsonKUjayhawks215]

I guess we also aint gonna act like Tennessee didnt win the BCS the YEAR AFTER peyton went ot the nfl

 

[nujerz84]

Eli in the 2 Min Drill and 4th Qtr>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Peyton in those situations