Black Boy King
New member
kai_valya;5314459 said:Perfect;5314416 said:kai_valya;5314356 said:Perfect;5314157 said:whether i agree with her sentiments or not, this is wrong on SOOOOOOO many levels. so now its "wrong" to THINK different?
will things like this not lead us to the point where its "wrong" to THINK?
kai_valya;5313972 said:one, people need to calm down
two, that is a terrible poem. do they not teach proper structure in that school? and it's just all over the place. if it was well written i'd have no complaints
its art. fuck structure.
if it's gonna be free verse, then have it all be free verse, don't have random rhyme schemes thrown in. not everything is art, some are just an attempt at art. not saying she should stop writing or anything, just giving an honest assessment of her work
objective critique is not an attack
im not saying you're attacking her, i'm saying the critique is redundant. you judged her intelligence from a poem that she didn't release to the public.
i think the actual story here is a student getting suspended over intellectual property because her teacher invaded her privacy
edit: and i think you meant objective criticism.. im just saynnnnnnn....
i never said she was dumb or speculated on her intelligence in any manner, just gave my opinion on the quality of her work
no, critique works well too
Amotekun;5314422 said:kai_valya;5314356 said:Perfect;5314157 said:whether i agree with her sentiments or not, this is wrong on SOOOOOOO many levels. so now its "wrong" to THINK different?
will things like this not lead us to the point where its "wrong" to THINK?
kai_valya;5313972 said:one, people need to calm down
two, that is a terrible poem. do they not teach proper structure in that school? and it's just all over the place. if it was well written i'd have no complaints
its art. fuck structure.
if it's gonna be free verse, then have it all be free verse, don't have random rhyme schemes thrown in. not everything is art, some are just an attempt at art. not saying she should stop writing or anything, just giving an honest assessment of her work
objective critique is not an attack
If its her first class then the primary concern
is just gettin a student open enough to express
thoughts...not first them into a box of structure.
If she were in an MFA program you'd be right but she's
17 in high school pimpin. It does suck though...but she
17, was it supposed to be good?
i didn't say it was supposed to be great, although i have seen pretty great work from young kids her age before. she should keep at it, but you can only improve with constructive criticism. everyone telling you it's great when it's not won't make you get better
You criticized her ability to write a structured poem. I'm saying that your opinion on the quality of the poem is redundant since it wasn't for the public to read to begin with. That's like going through an artist's laptop and critiquing music he hasn't released yet.
Though again, I don't think the issue is the quality of the poem... But if you want to make that the issue, then shouldn't she be in school learning how to write better rather than suspended for "poor work"?
Last edited: