Classic Or Not Vol 25 (Halloween Edition)............When The Smoke Clears............(Heated Race!)

[Bodhi]

lol god damn the poll is tied lmao

 

[Stew]

Is this the most feelings caught in a classic or not thread to date?

Between this and Trap Muzik by far

lol god damn the poll is tied lmao

Technically its 25-24 YES cause I caught an alias of somebody who already voted NO last night so Im not counting that shit. Going to 30 so niggas dont think im trynna cheat

 

[Matt-]

only because Chapter 2: World Domination is more of a classic to me. before they shifted their sound slightly. and i just can't give 3 6 two 'classic albums'

yet another way to discredit

"they already made an album just as good that I think is classic, so I can't give them 2 classics" smh

i did say that 3 6 isn't worthy of having 2 classic albums. but that was a separate point. why are you making up shit that i didn't say. i said World Domination was MORE of a classic. i never said that both albums were equally as good. now i see why people always shit on the reason.

 

[P. Town]

Is this the most feelings caught in a classic or not thread to date?

Between this and Trap Muzik by far

lol god damn the poll is tied lmao

Technically its 25-24 YES cause I caught an alias of somebody who already voted NO last night so Im not counting that shit. Going to 30 so niggas dont think im trynna cheat

That shit ain't fair. If you said a 25 count in a close race is a win then this needs to be in the vault. Don't bend the rules

 

[Stew]

Ive never had to deal with an alias voting either, for all I know NO couldve reached 25 before YES did overnight. Think Im doing the right thing by extending it to 30 and not counting that alias NO vote.

 

[vageneral08]

Is this the most feelings caught in a classic or not thread to date?

Between this and Trap Muzik by far

lol god damn the poll is tied lmao

Technically its 25-24 YES cause I caught an alias of somebody who already voted NO last night so Im not counting that shit. Going to 30 so niggas dont think im trynna cheat

U cheating ass....every vote counts nigga

 

[lamontbdc]

dope ass cd but it's not a classic everybody was bumping this cd heavy round the way

 

[P. Town]

If somebody had to create an alias to vote "No", not only is that lame as hell, but they real vote should be disqualified as well

 

[Stew]

Is this the most feelings caught in a classic or not thread to date?

Between this and Trap Muzik by far

lol god damn the poll is tied lmao

Technically its 25-24 YES cause I caught an alias of somebody who already voted NO last night so Im not counting that shit. Going to 30 so niggas dont think im trynna cheat

That shit ain't fair. If you said a 25 count in a close race is a win then this needs to be in the vault. Don't bend the rules

Is this the most feelings caught in a classic or not thread to date?

Between this and Trap Muzik by far

lol god damn the poll is tied lmao

Technically its 25-24 YES cause I caught an alias of somebody who already voted NO last night so Im not counting that shit. Going to 30 so niggas dont think im trynna cheat

U cheating ass....every vote counts nigga

See its a lose/lose for me either way lol

 

[Matt-]

this shit is personal huh?

 

[Stew]

this shit is personal huh?

I dont mind, makes for more interesting conversation. I know these last 5 votes either way are gonna take forever tho smh

 

[Brian B.]

Can someone who voted 'yes' explain to me HOW this album is classic besides "every song is dope".

I've seen folks on here call albums classic & even say there's a song or two they don't like.. can you explain that?

Influence on the genre as a whole.

Lmao.. basically what other folks think.. so, even if you don't like 1/2 the songs on a said "classic", but is heralded as one by everybody else, you say it is by default? Haha

 

[Brian B.]

only because Chapter 2: World Domination is more of a classic to me. before they shifted their sound slightly. and i just can't give 3 6 two 'classic albums'

yet another way to discredit

"they already made an album just as good that I think is classic, so I can't give them 2 classics" smh

i did say that 3 6 isn't worthy of having 2 classic albums. but that was a separate point. why are you making up shit that i didn't say. i said World Domination was MORE of a classic. i never said that both albums were equally as good. now i see why people always shit on the reason.

Lol I kno you didn't exactly say that, but the logic is used on here

"They already got a classic that's just as good, if not better, so I can't give them another classic"

is that better?

& why do some of yall bring up reasons to credit/discredit that have nothing to do w/ the music on said album being discussed?

"so & so dropped a better album that year"

"the impact it had"

"The amount it sold"

"but, they already have 1 classic"

haha

some of yall in here even say "music is subjective"

so, wouldn't that make classics too?

 

[Matt-]

only because Chapter 2: World Domination is more of a classic to me. before they shifted their sound slightly. and i just can't give 3 6 two 'classic albums'

yet another way to discredit

"they already made an album just as good that I think is classic, so I can't give them 2 classics" smh

i did say that 3 6 isn't worthy of having 2 classic albums. but that was a separate point. why are you making up shit that i didn't say. i said World Domination was MORE of a classic. i never said that both albums were equally as good. now i see why people always shit on the reason.

Lol I kno you didn't exactly say that, but the logic is used on here

"They already got a classic that's just as good, if not better, so I can't give them another classic"

is that better?

& why do some of yall bring up reasons to credit/discredit that have nothing to do w/ the music on said album being discussed?

"so & so dropped a better album that year"

"the impact it had"

"The amount it sold"

"but, they already have 1 classic"

haha

i don't know really. i admit, there isn't much logic involved other than classic is thrown around way too loosely so if i had to give a classic status to a 3-6 album, it would be world domination. not both world domination AND when the smoke clears. WD is a better album imo, but i'm pretty much a southern street dude raised on this shit so i watched them elvolve as a group and WD was sort of the peak for them using their orginal sound. But i can see how the mainstream would gravitate more towards when the smoke clears.

 

[MARIO_DRO]

IF THIS IS A CLASSIC, THEN GETTY GREEN AND MISTA DONT PLAY SHOULD BE IN THE RAP HALL OF FAME!

 

[_Goldie_]

Yea, we need to make a poll for those too. Both classics imo.

 

[Stew]

IF THIS IS A CLASSIC, THEN GETTY GREEN AND MISTA DONT PLAY SHOULD BE IN THE RAP HALL OF FAME!

^^^Proof that southern niggas are voting NO as well.

 

[Bodhi]

IF THIS IS A CLASSIC, THEN GETTY GREEN AND MISTA DONT PLAY SHOULD BE IN THE RAP HALL OF FAME!

Mista Don't Play is classic I don't give a fuck

 

[FyHunnit]

25 to 26, no. of this is a true classic, why is the doubt about it sooo overwhelming

 

[T. Sanford]

IF THIS IS A CLASSIC, THEN GETTY GREEN AND MISTA DONT PLAY SHOULD BE IN THE RAP HALL OF FAME!

You slick gotta debate with Mista Don't Play because that's the 2nd hardest album to come out under Hypnotized Minds but When The Smoke Clears>>>>>>>>>Ghetty Green