Classic Or Not RECAP Thread

[_Menace_]

When will American Gangster get its Nod? Lost Tapes too?

We need More NAS albums in, lol

I dropped untitled but it didnt get in... shouldve done Hip Hop Is Dead...instead

 

[DMTxTHC]

Murda Muzik is a classic... Smh...

 

[CoolJoe]

FNL is definitely a classic, only real gripe I have with this so far.

 

[P. Town]

I stopped caring about this after When the Smoke Clears got cheated

 

[DMTxTHC]

I stopped caring about this after When the Smoke Clears got cheated

What you mean by "cheated"?

 

[P. Town]

I stopped caring about this after When the Smoke Clears got cheated

What you mean by "cheated"?

They changed the rules after it had already won

 

[blackgod813]

Recount the Carter 2 we ready now

 

[BackInWhite]

the documentary ain't no fuckin classic

to be honest most of them shits ain't classic, they just old

 

[5th Letter]

that when the smoke clears thread was funny as hell.

 

[King Lee]

X's first album aint get in, whatttt

 

[ohhhla]

X's first album aint get in, whatttt

Are you serious? Can you read?

 

[Meta_Conscious]

Soul on I e was robbed...

 

[_Goldie_]

Ill say about 3 of those shouldnt be in the vault and 5 albums were robbed..

Soul Food

400 degrees

Tical

Food and liqour

The Documentary

I would say carter 2 and eminem show , but I know yall mfs anti weezy and em.........

But all those need a re count

 

[King Lee]

Ive had a few people ask whats been done before so here yo go.

1. Supreme Clientele- IN

2. Makaveli- IN

3. E 1999- IN

4. The Documentary- OUT

5. Life After Death- IN

6. Trap Muzik- IN

7. Get Rich Or Die Trying- IN

8. Capital Punishment- IN

9. Uptown Saturday Night- OUT

10. Soul Food- OUT smh

11. 400 Degreez- IN

12. Reasonable Doubt- IN

13. Ridin Dirty- IN

14. Late Registration- IN

15. Chronic 2001- IN

16. TM101- OUT

17. A Long Hot Summer- IN

18. The Carter 2- OUT

19. The Eminem Show- OUT

20. Food n Liquor- OUT

21. Southernplayalistc- IN

22. HNIC- OUT

23. Wu-Tang Forever- IN

24. No One Can Do It Better- IN

25. When The Smoke Clears- OUT

26. Death Certificate- IN

27. Stillmatic- IN

28. Tical- OUT

29. Doggystyle- IN

30. Muddy Waters- IN

31. Staight Outta Cashville- OUT

32. BE- IN

33. Soul On Ice- OUT

34. Do or Die- IN

35. Paid In Full- IN

36. Country Grammer- OUT

37. The Black Album- IN

38. Liquid Swords- IN

39. Dogg Food- IN

40. Its Dark And Hell Is Hot- OUT

41. Chopper City In The Ghetto- OUT

42. Ice Cream Man- OUT

43. UNTITLED- OUT

44. The Listening- OUT

45. Murda Muzik- OUT

46. IronMan- tbd

I was skimming and I saw this, nvm

 

[Peezy_Jenkins]

that when the smoke clears thread was funny as hell.

u woulda thought it was sad as hell if it got voted in tho

 

[704Hustla]

if get get rich or die tryin could get voted in as a classic then i dont see why carter 2 and tm101 got left out cause those albums were better

glad to see trap muzik in their though

 

[jono]

F&L should be in, but Lupe is almost Eminem status with the hate he gets.

 

[T. Sanford]

How is Liquid Swords a classic? that bull shss aint hip hop at all

 

[DMTxTHC]

F&L should be in, but Lupe is almost Eminem status with the hate he gets.

Nosign Lupe getting a lot of "hate".. I'll say this though, every rapper has it's moment every now and then where they get shitted on.. and I don't have a problem with F&L being in the vault..

 

[DMTxTHC]

How is Liquid Swords a classic?

Why is the sky blue?

Why is water wet?

Why did Judas rat to Romans while Jesus slept?