THE G.O.A.T. DEBATE: Biggie's 1st Two LP's -VS- Your Favorite Rapper's Best 3 LP's?

[ShadyTeam]

The Marshall Mathers LP>>>>>>>>Ready To Die & Life After Death

The Slim Shady LP>>>>>>>>>>>Ready To Die & Life After Death

Ready To Die>>>>>>>>>>The Eminem Show

The Eminem Show>>>>>>>>>Life After Death

 

[rapmastermind]

The Marshall Mathers LP>>>>>>>>Ready To Die & Life After Death

The Slim Shady LP>>>>>>>>>>>Ready To Die & Life After Death

Ready To Die>>>>>>>>>>The Eminem Show

The Eminem Show>>>>>>>>>Life After Death

So "Ready To Die" is better than the Eminem Show but not better than The Slim Shady LP or Marshal Matthers LP? SMH. "Life After Death" bodies The Eminem Show, it's not even close. Disc 1 of LAD alone bodies The Eminem Show. MMLP is the only Eminem album seeing Big's discography and even that falls short.

 

[usmarin3]

Biggies career is Gayle Sayers, just flashes of brilliance in his short time but you will never get me to say he is better than Nas and Jay imo because we've seen that they have stood the test of time, went on to make more classics, and had longevity. To say Big would of done that too is giving him the benefit of the doubt and i don't deal with that, i deal with what did happen. As far as Big, i don't know how he would of turned out because as much as people hates Puff, he was the mastermind behind Biggies sound and gave him direction.

I'll take Illmatic, IWW, and Stillmatic over - RTD,LAD

I'll take RD, Blueprint, and Black Album over - RTD, LAD

 

[rapmastermind]

Biggies career is Gayle Sayers, just flashes of brilliance in his short time but you will never get me to say he is better than Nas and Jay imo because we've seen that they have stood the test of time, went on to make more classics, and had longevity. To say Big would of done that too is giving him the benefit of the doubt and i don't deal with that, i deal with what did happen. As far as Big, i don't know how he would of turned out because as much as people hates Puff, he was the mastermind behind Biggies sound and gave him direction.

I'll take Illmatic, IWW, and Stillmatic over - RTD,LAD

I'll take RD, Blueprint, and Black Album over - RTD, LAD

Here's the thing though. "RTD and LAD" was like Big winning the championship back to back in his rookie year than his sophomore year. Big died with the belt man. As far as Biggie vs Jay and NaS:

RTD = ILLmatic

RTD > RD, I.W.W.,Stillmatic, Blueprint, Vol 2

LAD < ILLmatic

LAD = RD

LAD > I.W.W., Blueprint, Vol 2, Stillmatic

 

[boom]

BIG's first 2 albums are better than any other niggas First 2 albums.. or any rappers best 2 albums period.. but if you include 3 albums.. then Nas has BIG beat..

 

[rapmastermind]

BIG's first 2 albums are better than any other niggas First 2 albums.. or any rappers best 2 albums period.. but if you include 3 albums.. then Nas has BIG beat..

Because of "ILLmatic" NaS shockingly can compete with Big discography the most. But they both dropped in 1994 head to head and Big had more Impact but I believe "Ready To Die' and "ILLmatic" are equal or "ILLmatic" is slightly better. "Life After Death" is when Big surges ahead of NaS. "It Was Written" + "STILLmatic" is a lethal combonation to go up against "Life After Death" but I'd still give the edge to Big.

 

[boom]

Ready To Die is not equal to Illmatic .. and I'm BIG's biggest fan...

Life After Death is the most complete album of all time.. but Illmatic is the true essence of hip hop lyrically..

ready to die is slightly better than It Was Written ..

 

[kingblaze84]

Biggie is indeed a legend.....I agree, his first two albums can go against any two albums ever made, for any genre. I have Jay and 2pac over Biggie overall, but I am very confident if Biggie was to live longer, my list would be very different. Life After Death is an insanely good album that still gets play to this day, same with all his other albums (minus the Biggie duets).

 

[boom]

Biggie is indeed a legend.....I agree, his first two albums can go against any two albums ever made, for any genre. I have Jay and 2pac over Biggie overall, but I am very confident if Biggie was to live longer, my list would be very different. Life After Death is an insanely good album that still gets play to this day, same with all his other albums (minus the Biggie duets).

lol ..........

 

[Question Authority]

I'm just gonna repeat what I posted in Fazeem's thread...

I like Biggie. I consider myself a Biggie fan. What I don't like about Biggie is how he's put on a pedestal, as if he did something so much more profound, artistic, and/or creative than like popular hip-hop artists. This is where I feel he's overrated. He was great at what he did - making catchy rap music that was commercially accessible. That's merely it. His music was successful on the charts, but it was hardly exceptional, IMO.

Just because Biggie made music for top 40 radio and, in essence would commercialize the genre, doesn't make his music any better or more impactful than someone whose music didn't sell as well.

Nas' first two albums >>>> Biggie's first two albums.

Hell, Illmatic is better than Biggie's entire discography.

 

[rapmastermind]

Biggie is indeed a legend.....I agree, his first two albums can go against any two albums ever made, for any genre. I have Jay and 2pac over Biggie overall, but I am very confident if Biggie was to live longer, my list would be very different. Life After Death is an insanely good album that still gets play to this day, same with all his other albums (minus the Biggie duets).

Tupac of course can be put above Big because he's the biggest Icon in Hip Hop History. But even Pac knew, Big was a beast on the mic. Jay Z is the last disciple of Biggie and he just followed Big's lane so it's hard for me to ever put Jay above Big. Jay Z today = 2010 Biggie if he lived. "Born Again" and Duets" were weak albums but they still sold off the strenth of Biggie's presents on each album. Dispite the horrible cut and paste job Diddy did. "Dead Wrong" stands out and is one of the greatest songs of Biggie's career though it was recorded in 1993 when he was a rookie.

 

[ShadyTeam]

Biggie Small's definitley should be in everyones top 5 G.O.A.T. list's

Eminem>>>>Nas>>>>>Biggie Small's>>>>Kurupt>>>>>Andre 3000 = top 5 greatest of all time dead or alive

and 2pac is in the top 10 along with Rakim

I think Ice Cube, KRS-One, Kane & LL Cool J fit in some where in the top 30 G.O.A.T. list

Jay Z to me is some where outside the top 30 G.O.A.T. list just based on the fact he overall has a poor catalouge no other person has dropped as many poor Album's as him and had the same content majority wise for 14 years he has made 11 solo Album's with only one being a classic and atleast 5 of them being poor and as far as content it has mainly been about selling drug's and materialism his whole career

No one else has relied on other people featuring and doing their Hook's for them like Jay Z has wether it be from the likes of Mary J Blige, Alicia Key's, R Kelly or Beyonce doing his Hook's for him

Jay Z has also relied on big name Producers for every Album he has ever made the Production on every Album Jay Z has ever made has outshined his Lyricism and overall Song Writting

 

[boom]

I'm just gonna repeat what I posted in Fazeem's thread...

I like Biggie. I consider myself a Biggie fan. What I don't like about Biggie is how he's put on a pedestal, as if he did something so much more profound, artistic, and/or creative than like popular hip-hop artists. This is where I feel he's overrated. He was great at what he did - making catchy rap music that was commercially accessible. That's merely it. His music was successful on the charts, but it was hardly exceptional, IMO.

Just because Biggie made music for top 40 radio and, in essence would commercialize the genre, doesn't make his music any better or more impactful than someone whose music didn't sell as well.

Nas' first two albums >>>> Biggie's first two albums.

Hell, Illmatic is better than Biggie's entire discography.

No ...........

 

[Jaydafresh1]

I prefer RD and LAD to every other album listed in this thread. People toss the MM album out there, IMO it has not aged well. The replay value just is not there, AEOM as a whole did not age well either, anyone that puts AEOM on the same level is LAD is crazy. Me Against the World doesnt hold a candle to RD, LAD,BP,Vol1,Blackalbum, not even close. I dont throw Nas in there because even though I have owned or aquired every Nas album, I have just never been a flat out Nas fan. Would I bump 3 of his albums, sure I would, over BIGs...not so much.

Now I am a huuuuuge Biggie fan, so I can admit my opinion is biased, but I have never put Illmatic on my list of favorite albums, didnt when it dropped and I dont now.

I'm a firm believer that BIG could have dropped a great album in any era. This will obviously come down to opinion as everything else does.

Now, if Puff would just release Victory with BIG rapping all the verses. Or "On the Road to Riches.." with a decent beat. Or fuck it, the original LAD beats, like that OG version of RD that dropped a couple of years ago....kind of like this..

[video=youtube;nlpClCe-5e0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlpClCe-5e0[/video]

 

[rapmastermind]

Biggie Vs Lil Wayne

RTD & LAD > The Carter, The Carter II, The Carter III

Biggie Vs T.I.

RTD & LAD > Trap Muzik, Urban Legend, King

 

[NevaChange]

Biggie Vs Rakim

RTD & LAD = Paid in Full, Follow the Leader, Let The Rhythm Hit Em

Biggie Vs Ice Cube

RTD & LAD = AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted, Death Certificate, The Predator

^^ I'm going with these two. I think Paid In Full + Follow The Leader and Ammerikkkaz Most Wanted + Death Certificate are way better than Big's albums.

 

[isayas]

Biggie Vs Rakim

RTD & LAD = Paid in Full, Follow the Leader, Let The Rhythm Hit Em

Biggie Vs Ice Cube

RTD & LAD = AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted, Death Certificate, The Predator

^^ I'm going with these two. I think Paid In Full + Follow The Leader and Ammerikkkaz Most Wanted + Death Certificate are way better than Big's albums.

You're a funny individual, man. Don't you hate Rakim?

 

[NevaChange]

You're a funny individual, man. Don't you hate Rakim?

No.

Rakim fell the fuck off and couldn't change with the times, but Paid In Full and Follow The Leader were revolutionary, and are better than both biggie albums.

 

[illogics]

The same way ShadyTeam is the ultimate lay down and die type fan for Eminem, Rapmastermind is the equivalent when it comes to Biggie. Just know this before yall proceed with this nigga.

 

[Question Authority]

The same way ShadyTeam is the ultimate lay down and die type fan for Eminem, Rapmastermind is the equivalent when it comes to Biggie. Just know this before yall proceed with this nigga.

So you sayin it's a waste of time entertainin this nigga because he stuck in his ways?