GoodFellas vs Pulp Fiction... which film was better?

[kingofbama205]

I can't vote for either of these becuz I enjoyed them both equally...Both of these movies are 2 of my all time favorites...and I can't pick one

 

[rip.dilla]

'Fellas... C'mon son!!!

 

[the best 1]

I can't vote for either of these becuz I enjoyed them both equally...Both of these movies are 2 of my all time favorites...and I can't pick one

"Wait... what do you mean you can't fucking vote... do you have a fucking hand... it's easy... Good... Fucking... Fellas... you fucking Prick... we should fucking wack ya!"

 

[the best 1]

'fellas... C'mon son!!!

"what did i just tell you muthafucka!!!!"

 

[-Karl-]

I'm going with Pulp.

Simply because I've watched it so many times and am more likely to watch it again in the future.

 

[allied]

You don't need to post the trailers if you haven't seen them but now where the fuck you been? Anyway, I'm going with Goodfellas all day. I enjoy it more and it's just a better overall flim IMO.

 

[Ibex]

Damn tough call but I have to go with Goodfellas

 

[im_lux]

I think Pulp Fiction had individual scenes that can't be touched, instant classics. But it also had those weird Bruce Willis and his pedo fantasy girlfriend scenes and the equally weird John Travolta/Uma Thurman scenes. I skip over all of those scenes when I watch the movie.

But as far as Good Fellas goes I'll watch that start to finish. Classic movie. It gets my vote for best movie out of the two.

 

[rapmastermind]

"Goodfellas" is the better film and Cast but "Pulp Fiction" had the better script/story and lines. But "Goodfellas" gets my vote, that movie was just great. I love "Pulp Fiction" for what it brought to the game so it's Classic Status cannot be questioned but "Goodfellas" had Deniro and Pesci, come on now. EVen when I watch "Casino" another Classic, I can't help but think of them in "Goodfellas". A matter of fact, the 3 films they did together are all Classic Scorsece films, "Raging Bull, Goodfellas and Casino"

 

[the best 1]

I'm going with Pulp.

Simply because I've watched it so many times and am more likely to watch it again in the future.

..."Pulp Fiction!!!!!... HA!... That movie is a piece of shit!!!...HA HA... Pulp Fiction!!!"

 

[the best 1]

I think Pulp Fiction had individual scenes that can't be touched, instant classics. But it also had those weird Bruce Willis and his pedo fantasy girlfriend scenes and the equally weird John Travolta/Uma Thurman scenes. I skip over all of those scenes when I watch the movie.

But as far as Good Fellas goes I'll watch that start to finish. Classic movie. It gets my vote for best movie out of the two.

C/S...........

 

[desertrain10]

Pulp fiction... the dialogue alone was classic. the movie is full of quotables. and more memorable characters/scenes....

Good fellas is also a classic but Pulp Fiction to me was more innovative and fresh.... especially the non-linear editing

before than i never seen a movie like a Pulp Fiction while Good Fellas, even though it was well executed, just another gangster flick

and the Pulp Fiction soundtrack was >>>>

 

[desertrain10]

"Goodfellas" is the better film and Cast but "Pulp Fiction" had the better script/story and lines. But "Goodfellas" gets my vote, that movie was just great. I love "Pulp Fiction" for what it brought to the game so it's Classic Status cannot be questioned but "Goodfellas" had Deniro and Pesci, come on now. EVen when I watch "Casino" another Classic, I can't help but think of them in "Goodfellas". A matter of fact, the 3 films they did together are all Classic Scorsece films, "Raging Bull, Goodfellas and Casino"

better cast? really?

pulp fictition features the likes of samuel l. jackson, bruce willis, uma thurman, ving rhames, christopher walken, harvey keital, john travolta, tim roth, steve bucemi..... and i could go on

ok i guess....

 

[ocelot]

damn.. its like asking which of your children is your favorite

 

[NAWLEDGE_REIGNS]

Comparing One The Greatest Movies Of All Time To The One Best Movies Of 1994 Is An Insult

Master>>>Student

Scorsese >>>Tarantino

Goodfellas >>>>>>>>>Pulp Fiction

 

[rapmastermind]

better cast? really?

pulp fictition features the likes of samuel l. jackson, bruce willis, uma thurman, ving rhames, christopher walken, harvey keital, john travolta, tim roth, steve bucemi..... and i could go on

ok i guess....

Don't get me wrong, "Pulp" cast was superb in every since of the word and it brought Travolta back but let's be real:

Denrio, Pesci and most of the cast of the "Soproans" >>>>>>>>>>>>>

Also for the record, Sam was in "Goodfellas" 1st, lol.

 

[the best 1]

Comparing One The Greatest Movies Of All Time To The One Best Movies Of 1994 Is An Insult

Master>>>Student

Scorsese >>>Tarantino

Goodfellas >>>>>>>>>Pulp Fiction

"I need you to help me understand how Pulp Fiction is "only" one of the best movies on 1994... thats all I'm asking"

 

[darkrain]

I love both movie but I am going Goodfellas because it's based on a true story, shit happened in real life.

 

[Disciplined InSight]

Goodfellas of course...

I'm a fan of both directors Tarantino and Scorsese though.

 

[radaman]

Goodfellas................