Eli > Peyton ?

[its....JOHN B]

give me eli in a big game, peyton is similar to lebron in the clutch

 

[woah316]

Yea we know that Peyton has all the numbers . But in the biggest games against the best teams , Eli shows up big time . IMO he has won 3 games that Peyton would have never won. The 2 Playoff games in Lambeau , And the Superbowl against the Patriots . Peyton in big games has been known to come up small .

The Giants D held an undefeated Tom Brady team with the best offense in NFL history to 14 points

The Giants D held another team that coulda easily been 16-0, with 1 of the best offensive years a QB ever had in NFL history (sound eerie?), to 20 points, coulda easily been 6.. Packs caught a lot of breaks.

Do you want to discuss this further or do you want to ask a mod to delete this thread?

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

In the clutch?

Absolutely. He's one of many QB's I'd take over Manning

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

The Giants D held an undefeated Tom Brady team with the best offense in NFL history to 14 points

The Giants D held another team that coulda easily been 16-0, with 1 of the best offensive years a QB ever had in NFL history (sound eerie?), to 20 points, coulda easily been 6.. Packs caught a lot of breaks.

Do you want to discuss this further or do you want to ask a mod to delete this thread?

The same giants d that gave up the lead with 2 mins left in the SB? where Eli had to drive his team down the field Joe Montana style for the win?

Be honest Peyton wouldve choked in that situation.(Rewatches Saints SB)

 

[woah316]

The same giants d that gave up the lead with 2 mins left in the SB? where Eli had to drive his team down the field Joe Montana style for the win?

Be honest Peyton wouldve choked in that situation.(Rewatches Saints SB)

Nigga they held the pats to 14 points, PERIOD. Brady just passed for 5 TDs in a half yesterday, with a worse offense than he had that year. And they held him to 14 points for the WHOLE GAME?

I suppose you going to ignore that.

 

[Mrslim1]

The Giants D held an undefeated Tom Brady team with the best offense in NFL history to 14 points

The Giants D held another team that coulda easily been 16-0, with 1 of the best offensive years a QB ever had in NFL history (sound eerie?), to 20 points, coulda easily been 6.. Packs caught a lot of breaks.

Do you want to discuss this further or do you want to ask a mod to delete this thread?

Well we know that D had a big part to do with it . But lets get real nobody really gives a fuck about the D . This is a QB league. And also in those games Eli showed up big . Also another reason I like Eli better is because he aint no bitch . When they won the bowl , Tiki Barber was talking shit at the beginning of the season , Eli basically said fuck you and lead them to a title . This year he jumped out there and said I am a Elite QB . Alot of people laughed at Eli . But he went out to perform like a Elite QB .

 

eli is more calm and strong willed than peyton and it shows .........

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

And they gave up the LEAD...

And who drove his team down the field in the SB?

Eli.(Eli was great the whole game, but closed it out in Epic style)

I can't see Peyton doing the same

 

[woah316]

Well we know that D had a big part to do with it . But lets get real nobody really gives a fuck about the D . This is a QB league. And also in those games Eli showed up big . Also another reason I like Eli better is because he aint no bitch . When they won the bowl , Tiki Barber was talking shit at the beginning of the season , Eli basically said fuck you and lead them to a title . This year he jumped out there and said I am a Elite QB . Alot of people laughed at Eli . But he went out to perform like a Elite QB .

I can look at Eli for 5 plays and tell you he's an Elite QB. Anyone who says he's not doesn't know football.

Peyton. is more valuable to his team, period.

OH and for the guy who said Peyton is a choker, the year the dude won the Superbowl he came back from 18 down to beat the rival pats. If that aint clutch I don't know what is.

 

[woah316]

And they gave up the LEAD...

And who drove his team down the field in the SB?

Eli.(Eli was great the whole game, but closed it out in Epic style)

I can't see Peyton doing the same

So basically you saying a defense sucks if it gives up a lead? You're retarded bro. You look at the game as a whole, not 1 quarter or part of a quarter.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

All I gotta say is.. Down 4 with 2 mins left to go in a big game, who do you want Peyton or Eli?

Honestly

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

So basically you saying a defense sucks if it gives up a lead? You're retarded bro. You look at the game as a whole, not 1 quarter or part of a quarter.

Where did I say they sucked?

Did they give up the lead with the season on the line?

Yes, who saved them with an ALL TIME great clutch drive?

Eli

 

[Mrslim1]

And they gave up the LEAD...

And who drove his team down the field in the SB?

Eli.(Eli was great the whole game, but closed it out in Epic style)

I can't see Peyton doing the same

In a similar situation against the Saints, Peyton threw a pick 6 that lost the bowl

 

[R.D.]

why yall entertaining this thread ?

 

[Already Home_17]

niggas cannot be serious right now

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

In a similar situation against the Saints, Peyton threw a pick 6 that lost the bowl

He choked.

Eli
Brady
Big Ben
Joe montana
Peyton
For example have all had a chance to either WIN or LOSE the Superbowl in the 4th quarter.

Peyton throws the interception to lose it

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

And for the record, of course Peyton is better.

Eli is more clutch by FAR tho

 

[MR.CJ]

Elite Manning>>>>>Peyton Manning

 

[Mrslim1]

And for the record, of course Peyton is better.

Eli is more clutch by FAR tho

And that my main point . In the Biggest games Eli doesnt fold like Peyton . And isnt that what its all about playing your best in the biggest games . Eli is more reliable . Even tho he is goofy as hell

 

[aneed123]

And that my main point . In the Biggest games Eli doesnt fold like Peyton . And isnt that what its all about playing your best in the biggest games . Eli is more reliable . Even tho he is goofy as hell

both are Clutch. Eli is a lil clutcher. Eli has nutted up in the playoffs vs the Eagles 2 years ago