AJ Styles couldn't cut a promo to save his life but he has had better matches than Seth. At the same time I don't think Seth hurt people in the ring other than himself recently like AJ has done.
seth seems a lil bit smoother imo, but i been watchin aj damn near since i first started watching (and he started actually) wrestling, so there's a few more memories. tough call
Giving the edge to Styles because of his TNA title reign being more of an impact. He adapted Ric Flairs technical skills at wrestling and perfected the figure 4 leg lock. Also the styles clash >>> Cesaros piledriver and Seths pedigree.
Seth only cuz he had a believable match with a monster brock lesner until taker stepped in....
as strong as they were booking brock at the time, a entertaining match should have been damn near impossible but he pulled it off....
my ONLY gripe with that match was that seth should have snuck in for the pin after the taker choke slam......but they were booking brock super strong at the time...