Ben Rothlisberger, Eli Manning, or Phillip Rivers

[iStayWinnin]

Big Ben......

 

[Dick Shitman]

Ben

Rivers

Eli

 

[Chef_Taylor]

big ben..of course

 

[sTaY_TrUe]

Big Ben then Eli

 

[usmarin3]

I'll take Rivers, he is just the better overall qb. People will point to the rings, but who cares he didn't have a defense to give him one or two.

 

[5th Letter]

Rivers is the better of the 3 QB's but oddly he's the one without any rings.

 

[makaveli4ever]

Rivers is the most talented. Give me Ben though. He is a big game qb.

 

[TdotGoHARD87]

Big Ben then Eli

^^^^^^^^^^i feel dat

 

[DoUwant2go2Heaven]

Rivers by a landslide.

Ben can get it done and he proved it in the super bowl, but I would still take Rivers over him.

Eli....LOL

 

[Rated R]

Rivers...........

 

[allied]

Rivers...........

The Rivers supporters have to be quiet for a while. I'll go with Big Ben.

 

[one_manshow]

Big Ben's career resume>>>>>Rivers meaningless season stats and playoff choking

 

[bow to royalty]

Think I may go with Rivers. Big Ben is good, but also a lot of luck. Not hating, but you can only break tackles and end up getting a 20 yard pass off so many times. Big Ben's gonna have to change that part of his game. And we've seen Eli Manning just crumble, although he can be good when he's playing well.

 

[Dick Shitman]

Think I may go with Rivers. Big Ben is good, but also a lot of luck. Not hating, but you can only break tackles and end up getting a 20 yard pass off so many times. Big Ben's gonna have to change that part of his game. And we've seen Eli Manning just crumble, although he can be good when he's playing well.

Why change it? It's gotten him 2 super bowls.

 

[bow to royalty]

Why change it? It's gotten him 2 super bowls.

His defense got him that. Don't get me wrong, Ben did do his part to help them win. But his defense helps give him a lot of slack in his QB play. Look at this year...Troy got hurt and missed much of the year, and they didn't even make the playoffs. But I think he needs to change it, because he won't lasts too long playing like that. You start breaking less tackles, you take more hits, you start to make more mistakes because you hold onto the ball too long.

 

[ya boi g]

Rivers seems like the most talented and Ben seems like the better leader....

If I already had a decent running game id take Ben.......

 

[Dick Shitman]

His defense got him that. Don't get me wrong, Ben did do his part to help them win. But his defense helps give him a lot of slack in his QB play. Look at this year...Troy got hurt and missed much of the year, and they didn't even make the playoffs. But I think he needs to change it, because he won't lasts too long playing like that. You start breaking less tackles, you take more hits, you start to make more mistakes because you hold onto the ball too long.

I'll give you the first super bowl, but Ben won that second one. That defense held em in the first 3 quarters but fell apart in the 4th and Roethlisberger took over. They didnt make the playoffs but Ben got his: 4300 yards, 26 tds despite having a shitty line. He's been playing like that his whole career so I cant see him changing after he's had success with it. Its like Favre, he's going to force passes for better or worse. Ben is gonna fight off lineman for better or worse

 

[swadesw]

Rivers is the most talented. Give me Ben though. He is a big game qb.

No hes not have u seen him throw the deep ball.... He cant throw over the shoulder passes yet everytime his ridiculous 6 foot 5 receivers come down with it... put rivers on another team and hes a nobody...

 

[nujerz84]

Ben, Eli then Rivers in that order. People stay hating on Eli he a pro bowl caliber player and had a career season this year.

 

[ef cuttin2.0]

I'll take Ben...Rivers is a dynamic QB,but he acts like a WR...the QB should be the 'cool' head in the huddle,not the one jawing with defenders IMO...and Eli, well...no.